La Traviata (part of D’Opéra Malta: Paris Concert Edition) – MuzikArt Ltd at Teatru Salesjan, Sliema, Malta

‘You really couldn’t make this amateurish approach up; unfortunately, someone did and I came away feeling somewhat cheated: Maltese audiences deserve better’

Presented as a special chamber production offering a shortened version of the opera without losing its emotional depth or dramatic power, this reimagination sadly comes up short on pretty much every other metric too.

We open with Violetta (Ana Oniani), aided by her friend Flora (Valentina Cotrone), hosting a lavish party where she is introduced to Alfredo Germont (Taras Korol), a fervent admirer, who is concerned for her failing health. When Alfredo declares his love for her, she wonders if he could be the one amidst her desire to be free to live her life.

A year on and Alfredo and Violetta have been living together for some time in an isolated country house. Upon discovering that Violetta is having to sell her possessions to maintain them, he hurries to Paris to sort his affairs. His father, Giorgio (Ihor Mostovoi) arrives and endeavours to persuade Violetta to end the relationship.

At a party in Paris, Flora is amazed to discover that Alfredo and Violetta are no longer together. The arrival of Alfredo followed by Violetta leads to an inevitable confrontation. As we are thrust towards our final scene, is there time for wounds to be healed?

Any expectation of a concert staging was quickly dispelled upon discovering that there was only the primary cast of four – with a couple of walk on extras – accompanied by a pianist (Tetiana Boilo) throughout and a violinist (Heorhii Vasyliev) for some scenes. Indeed, these are introduced by a Narrator (Nicholas Jackman) who effectively gives away the full reveal for each scene/act before the curtains are drawn back and the cast appear in costume with some minor props and a changing backdrop to suit location and perform a limited selection of arias and duets. Whilst Jackman’s Irish lilt is pleasant sounding enough, he almost seems as surprised as we are when he appears and, disappointingly, is in desperate need of his notes to tell us what happens next.

Boilo’s accompaniment is reasonable but whether it was a combination of occasional wrong notes or a poorly tuned piano, there were too many instances when it sounded off-key, none of which is helped by the lack of other instruments to embellish the arrangement. Vasyliev, in contrast, appears fleetingly, but played with composure, adding real emotion to those scenes.

Oniani is a powerful soprano, but she needs to learn to dial down from eleven and bring some depth and emotion to her vocal otherwise it is just loud and monotonous which was reflected in her struggles at the higher range. I wondered several times whether she understood Violetta’s heartfelt story.

Korol’s singing was passable but he also struggled with his range, and I got no sense of Alfredo’s emotional vulnerability or sensitivity from his performance. In contrast, Mostovoi captured the simmering anger of Giorgio, with a decent vocal although struggled at times at the top of his range.

Cotrone has a limited role but performed well with a sweet vocal. I do wonder whether she could have been doubled up as the maid in Act II Scene I, and Act III to strengthen the presentation of the story.

There are no credits provided for anyone else involved or associated with the production.

I’ve written at length about ‘show don’t tell’ yet here we have a timeless masterpiece that does all the work for you through some of opera’s most beautiful music and wonderful libretto, and which can be staged in any number of ways to suit a budget, but the company has upended all of that for what purpose, one can only guess at: the ticket prices were certainly not cheap.

Including the interruptions of the narrator, Acts I and II were played unbroken for ninety minutes before a fifteen-minute interval, following which we received a further narration full of spoilers for five minutes before fifteen minutes of Act III. You really couldn’t make this amateurish approach up; unfortunately, someone did and I came away feeling somewhat cheated: Maltese audiences deserve better.

On the subject of audiences, the behaviour of many tonight was atrocious with people taking photos and videoing on their smartphones throughout – the illumination of which is incredibly distracting – as well as people scrolling through their social media, although perhaps that reflects more on the performance itself. Staff at the venue suggested the onus was on the company to announce any restrictions, although I have to say, I think the venue owe a duty to all audience members who have paid handsomely to attend.

Muzikart Ltd claims to not just create music, but to create the emotion behind your event. They weren’t good ones tonight, but you can be the judge of that and find out more about them at https://www.muzikartevent.com/

Established in 1908, Teatru Salesjan is a performance space and a hub for community engagement in the heart of Sliema and is a rather delightful venue with friendly and helpful staff. To find out more and details of upcoming productions go to https://tsmalta.com/

Reviewer: Mark Davoren

Review Date: 7th November 2026

Star Rating: ONE

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *