‘A ghostly tale of mystery and deceit’

The Mystery of Sleepy Hollow is an original play written by Elliot Kinnear based on Washington Irving’s classic 1820 story The Legend of Sleepy Hollow and the cast of characters are taken from the original story.
The story follows Henry Fisher (Evan Dunn) who arrives at Sleepy Hollow on New Years Eve 1799 to uncover the mysterious disappearance of Ichabod Crane resulting in a ghostly tale of mystery, deceit and the consequences the villagers must pay. Henry Fisher soon finds himself caught up in the mystery of the Headless Horseman and the fear it provokes in the village.
For twenty years the villagers have not set foot outside their houses from when it goes dark until sunrise for fear of the Headless Horseman. They have rituals to protect themselves and strongly belief that this keeps them safe. The exception was Ichabod Crane, the local schoolmaster, who was trying to win the hand of Katrina (Rachel Wakefield-Ray) but one evening, against all advice, leaves the van Tassel household to ride home alone on his horse never to be seen again.
Was he a victim of the Headless Horseman or are there other dark arts at play?
Abraham “Brom Bones” van Brunt (Lee Patterson) gives a commanding performance at the start setting the scene of Sleepy Hollow and its mysteries. Abraham van Brunt has won the hand of Katrina who he loves deeply but she is haunted by the disappearance of her true love Ichabod Crane and carries around a memento in his memory.
As Henry Fisher tries digging into the mysteries of the village he is strongly advised by the villagers not to delve too deeply and is offered a bed for the night by Baltus van Tassel (Roger Hesketh) and his wife Aletta van Tassel (Jamie Morgan). Baltus and Aletta van Tassel appear to be regarded as the most respected people in the village but are they hiding secrets?
The sunrise on New Years Day does not appear leading to many questions being asked by Henry Fisher and many explanations given. Will the villagers survive until the sun rises, will they become victims of the Headless Horseman or is there another reason the sun has not yet risen?
As the story develops, we realise that Henry Fisher has arrived in Sleepy Hollow with a different purpose and he knows the true scale of the villagers fear as they are hiding secrets from twenty years ago and its time for everyone to face the consequences of their actions including Henry Fisher as we discover his part in the Mystery of Sleepy Hollow.
Interventions along the way from Reverend Linden (Keith Hill), Justice Thyssen (Tom Herbert) and Brouwer Thyssen (Joseph Rutland) all trying to protect their community from Fisher’s questions along with Marshall Kneynsberg (Sy Boyce) and Hans van Ripper (Mike Webster). Helga (Rebecca Herbert) also tries to protect the village and Rebekah (Aleczandra Wharton) who is an outcast in the village does her best to guide Fisher to the truth.
A mention needs to be given to Jamie Morgan who as Aletta van Tassel was excellent portraying the desire to protect her daughter and the desire to protect the secrets of twenty years ago.
The costumes (Julie Khayati) were perfect for the period and the attention to detail was immaculate. The set design (Terry Collister and Mike Harrison) was well thought out and again absolutely suited to the period.
The lighting (Georgie Grogan-Morrell) was suitable atmospheric and helped set the scene along with the excellent sound effects (Alex Wakefield-Ray) which brought the Headless Horseman to life.
The play loses its way a little bit towards the end of the second half and could do with being a bit shorter but The Mystery of Sleepy Hollow is ideal for the Halloween season and offers a what happened scenario after the disappearance of Ichabod Crane, was the Headless Horseman really to blame or was it the villagers’ actions of twenty years ago?
Reviewer: Ann Smith
Review Date: 31st October 2026
Star Rating: THREE
